Toxic Backlinks: 7 Checks I Run Before I Disavow Anything

Toxic Backlinks: 7 Checks I Run Before I Disavow Anything

Toxic backlinks are links from spammy, hacked or manipulative pages that point at your site. That is the textbook answer. The honest answer is that most links an SEO tool labels as toxic backlinks are harmless junk that Google already ignores, and a small number are real problems that need you to act. My job, whenever a client forwards me a scary audit report, is telling those two groups apart before anyone touches a disavow file.

I have built and cleaned up links since 2019, and I run the same seven checks every time. Here they are, in order, with the decision I make at the end of each one.

What toxic backlinks really are (and what the tools mean)

Google does not use the word “toxic” in its documentation. It talks about link spam: buying or selling links that pass ranking credit, large-scale link exchanges, automated programs that create links, and keyword-stuffed links hidden in widgets or footers. You can read the full list in Google’s spam policies. The word “toxic” comes from SEO tools, which give each referring domain a risk score based on patterns they have learned to associate with spam.

That difference matters. A tool sees a forum profile from a site in another language with a DR of 2 and marks it red. Google sees the same link and, in most cases, simply gives it zero weight. With the December 2022 link spam update, Google said its AI system SpamBrain works to neutralize the impact of unnatural links. Neutralized is not the same as harmful.

Ahrefs reached a similar view in its own article on whether toxic backlinks are worth worrying about, and I agree with most of it. Where I differ slightly: links you or a past agency built on purpose are a different story from random spam, and that is the line most audits never draw.

What the tool flagsWhat it usually isReal risk
Scraper sites copying your postsAutomated content theftVery low, Google ignores most of it
Foreign-language spam directoriesOld link lists nobody visitsVery low
Stats and “website worth” pagesAuto-generated domain reportsVery low
Exact-match anchors from unrelated blogsOften a paid placement or PBNMedium to high, especially if you paid
Hundreds of links from one networkA link scheme, maybe built by a past vendorHigh
Links in hacked pages (pharma, casino text)Negative SEO or hacked sitesLow unless the volume is huge

The 7 checks I run on toxic backlinks

I work through these in this order because the first two answer the question for most sites in under ten minutes. If both come back clean, I usually stop there.

1. Is there a manual action?

Open Search Console, go to Security and Manual Actions, then Manual actions. If you see “Unnatural links to your site”, stop reading audits and start cleaning, because Google has already decided. If it says “No issues detected”, your toxic backlinks are, at worst, being ignored. That one screen changes the whole conversation.

2. Did anyone build these links on purpose?

This is the question I ask every client, and it is the one that matters most. Random spam that found you on its own is noise. Links that you, a freelancer or an old agency paid for, swapped or created with software are a pattern Google is built to look for. I ask for old invoices, vendor reports and the dates of past campaigns, then line those dates up against the link graph.

3. Do the rankings line up with the links?

Toxic backlinks get blamed for every traffic drop. Before I believe it, I put the Search Console clicks graph next to the “new referring domains” graph from any backlink tool. If the drop happened in the same week as a core update and the spam links arrived months earlier, the links are probably not the cause. If a drop came right after a burst of exact-match links, that is worth a closer look.

4. What does the anchor text look like?

Spam that was never meant for you tends to use random anchors, your naked URL or gibberish. Links that were built to rank tend to use your money keyword again and again. Export your anchors and paste them into my free anchor text ratio checker. If exact-match anchors make up a large share of the profile, read my notes on anchor text over optimization before you decide anything.

5. Open the linking page, not just the domain

Scores are built on domains. Problems live on pages. I open a sample of flagged URLs, at least twenty, and look at three things: is the page indexed, does it read like something a person wrote, and how many other outbound links sit around mine. A page with 300 outbound links to unrelated businesses is a link farm. A thin directory page from 2014 is just old.

6. Is it a network?

One weak link is nothing. Forty links from forty sites that share the same theme, the same author bio, the same hosting and the same “write for us” page is a network, and networks are what Google acts against. Group flagged domains by IP range, template and owner details where the tool allows it. Clusters stand out fast.

7. Can I get it removed?

For links you paid for, removal beats disavowal. Google’s own disavow help page says to try getting the links taken down first, and to disavow only when you have a considerable number of spammy or artificial links and they have caused, or are likely to cause, a manual action. A short, polite email to the site owner works more often than people expect, especially when the vendor who sold the link has gone quiet.

A worked example (hypothetical numbers)

Say your audit tool flags 400 referring domains as toxic backlinks on a site with 1,200 referring domains in total. That looks terrifying in a dashboard. Here is how the seven checks would usually sort it.

  • Manual Actions shows no issues, so there is no emergency.
  • Say 330 of the 400 are scrapers, stats pages and foreign directories with random anchors. You leave them alone. Google has seen this kind of thing on every site on the web.
  • Say 45 come from blogs a past agency used, with your main keyword as the anchor. These are the ones I care about. You email the owners and ask for removal.
  • Say 25 sit on one obvious network with the same template. Those go in the disavow file at domain level if removal fails.

In that scenario, a 400-row problem becomes a 70-row job, and only part of that ends up in a disavow file. The exact split is different on every site, but the shape is usually similar: a long tail of noise and a short list of links someone chose to build. The full process for building the file itself, with Google’s format rules and a sample, is in my guide to a disavow list.

What I do with toxic backlinks: ignore, remove or disavow

SituationMy actionWhy
Random spam, no manual action, rankings stableIgnoreGoogle already discounts it, and a disavow adds risk for no gain
Paid or swapped links, no manual action yetAsk for removal, then disavow what staysThis is the “likely to cause a manual action” case Google describes
Manual action for unnatural linksRemove, disavow the rest, file a reconsideration requestGoogle wants to see real cleanup effort, not just a file
Sudden flood of spam during a negative SEO attackWatch for two to four weeks, disavow the domains only if rankings moveMost attacks do nothing, but keep records in case they do

One practical note. The disavow tool works with URL-prefix properties in Search Console, not Domain properties. If your site is verified only as a Domain property, add a URL-prefix version first.

Negative SEO: should you panic?

Every few months a client sends me a screenshot of thousands of new links with casino or pharma anchors and asks if a competitor is attacking them. Sometimes it is an attack. More often it is a hacked site network spraying links at anything that ranks. In both cases my advice is the same: note the date, export the list, and watch rankings. If nothing moves, nothing needs doing. If rankings fall and the timing fits, disavow those domains in one batch and keep the export as proof.

Mistakes I see with toxic backlinks

  • Disavowing everything the tool marks red. I have seen files with good editorial links inside them because a tool did not like the site’s design. Removing value is a real cost.
  • Trusting one tool’s score. Different tools score the same domain very differently. Use the score to sort the list, never to decide.
  • Blaming links for a content problem. If a core update hit you, the cause is usually on the page. Check your on-page SEO before you blame the backlink profile.
  • Uploading a new file that overwrites the old one. A new upload replaces the previous disavow file, so always add to the existing list instead of starting fresh.
  • Buying more of the same links after cleanup. If a vendor’s links caused the problem, the vendor is the problem. My breakdown of paid backlinks covers what separates a safe placement from a risky one.

My toxic backlinks checklist

  1. Check Manual Actions in Search Console.
  2. List every past link campaign, vendor and date.
  3. Compare traffic drops with link spikes and core update dates.
  4. Export anchors and check the exact-match share.
  5. Open at least 20 flagged pages by hand.
  6. Group flagged domains to find networks.
  7. Request removal for links you paid for or swapped.
  8. Disavow only what is left, at domain level, and keep a dated copy.

If you just want a quick look at what links to your site before going through the list, start with my walkthrough on how to check backlinks with free tools.

Toxic backlinks FAQ

Do toxic backlinks hurt SEO?

Random spam links rarely do, because Google ignores most of them. Links that were bought, swapped or built at scale can hurt, either through a manual action or by being discounted after you relied on them. The risk depends on intent and volume, not on a tool’s score.

How do I find toxic backlinks for free?

Use the Links report in Google Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools, sort the top linking sites, and open the suspicious ones by hand. Ahrefs Webmaster Tools is also free and shows referring domains for sites you have verified.

Should I disavow all toxic backlinks?

No. Google’s own guidance is to disavow only when you have a lot of spammy or artificial links and they have caused, or are likely to cause, a manual action. For most sites that is never.

How long does it take for a disavow to work?

Google processes the file as it recrawls the linked pages, so it can take weeks or months. If you are under a manual action, the reconsideration request is what gets reviewed, and that usually takes a few weeks.

Can a competitor hurt me with toxic backlinks?

It is possible but uncommon. Google says it works to neutralize unnatural links, and most negative SEO attempts have no visible effect. Keep a dated export, watch your rankings, and disavow only if a drop clearly lines up with the attack.

The short version

Toxic backlinks are worth checking, not worth panicking over. Look for a manual action, find out who built what, and focus your time on the links someone made on purpose. Leave the background spam alone. If you would like a second pair of eyes on an audit, or you want new links built the clean way so this never comes up, my link building services page explains how I work.